


|
|
|
|
Search
05/20/2025 Rod Tomczak, DPM, MD, EdD
Podiatry and Cardiac Escape Beats
It should be no secret, but most podiatrists won’t admit podiatry is dying. We are podiatry and many of us see the white light. The guys out here in the field are podiatry. If somehow all the podiatry alphabet organizations existed with no podiatrists seeing patients every day, there would be no such thing as podiatry. For some reason though, the alphabet people are trying to keep us from seeing that ECG that reveals prominent escape beats that often herald cardiac arrest.
APMA is at the top of the podiatry flow chart and it doesn’t want us to see the profession is deteriorating around us. The why they don’t want us to see is because the alphabet organizations think they have some miracle medication that will fix the inevitable cardiac arrest. We wish podiatry wasn’t crashing, but it is.
There are two important indicators that have surfaced of late. One was the PM News survey that revealed only 13% of the 690 respondents were happy with their DPM degree and a three-year residency; essentially the status quo. Eighty-six percent of those replying would prefer a DO degree. A DO degree for us worker bees is unlikely for those who replied since a DO degree would mean we would have to drop everything, go back to school and incur additional debt.
It does apply to those individuals in college and younger. For them a DO degree is very possible. There will soon be 37 DO schools with seats to fill and those seats will be very appealing to potential podiatry students. Recently, Kevin Smith, DPM, PhD the dean of the Des Moines College of Podiatric Medicine wrote in his doctoral dissertation from the University of Nebraska at Lincoln, that today’s DPM students are clearly capable of completing all the work necessary for a DO degree including passing the national board exams required to license as a DO. He did not show a head to head comparison, but his metrics when compared with the research of others show DPM students have the tools required to complete a DO degree and earn a plenary medical license. They have seats in their colleges that will go to qualified students.
Let me be clear. Students do not want a partial license and a three year residency which DPM schools are the pathway to; new DO schools have more seats that will go to capable students; potential DPM students can fill those seats and not be frustrated. But in the course of that action they will be leaving DPM seats unfilled. Earlier this year I shared that as of March, there were 318 total applicants to the 11 podiatry schools. That does not mean that 318 students had been interviewed, accepted, made a deposit to reserve a DPM seat or indicated they would be attending podiatry school.
Most of us who have been around long enough to develop mycotic toenails know that about half the number of the March total applicants would be present our first day of podiatry school. AACPM was very forth coming in March but as I wrote succeeding editorials for PM News highlighting more DO seats, AACPM has become less accessible concerning application numbers, or by this time acceptance numbers. I have been trying to get an update on what should be information available to at least, every podiatrist.
As of this week, AACPM will not answer or even acknowledge my calls. Put in simpler terms, all calls to AACPM from my cell phone go to voice mail telling me no one is available and to call back. No one answers the calls during normal business hours. I assume AACPM is able to recognize my cell phone number and I get shuffled to a recorded message that no one is available. On my first call to AACPM earlier in the week the live operator told me the person who compiled and shared the March application information would return my calls but she was not in the office and that she had to go home because of a family emergency.
Now, I don’t even get to talk to a real person at AACPM. I speculate the applicant numbers are not sufficient to support 11 podiatry school faculty salaries and other overhead and AACPM fears I would disclose this on the PM News forum. We’re going to find out the truth sooner or later. Based on prior information, i.e. the PM News survey and the increasing numbers of newly accredited DO colleges and unnecessary DPM schools, it appears undergraduate pre med students who would have matriculated at one of the podiatry colleges are no longer interested in becoming podiatrists.
I won’t speculate as to these students’ graduate school destination or ponder whether they are even going into a healthcare field. It does appear osteopathy is waxing and podiatry in waning to the point that the podiatry ECG is replete with those escape beats.
A Code Blue is imminent and maybe a relatively normal sinus rhythm will be restored as it always has been. As I said earlier, we are podiatry, and we are resilient. But why does this scenario keep repeating? We are constantly left in the dark by the podiatry alphabet organizations from the APMA down. No one is to blame, but we are still left in the dark. The APMA believes in the mushroom theory of leadership for all us constituents who make up podiatry. We are kept in the dark and nourished with what I’ll call organic fertilizer.
Is there a reason I can’t be told how many applicants there are to podiatry schools? Who ultimately made that decision? Doesn’t it look bad to the readers of this post that AACPM won’t tell me information that should be public but keeps it a close guarded national secret or simply won’t divulges information that will be public in a couple months? Are the top heavy alphabet organizations afraid of criticism, especially knowing it is our dollars that support them? It’s like telling the cop who stops you for a DUI that it’s your tax dollars that pay his salary.
Maybe AACPM thinks it will discover a Deus ex Machina between now and the start of Fall classes in 2025 and we will have 1100 total podiatry students starting this August. That way we won’t be able to criticize AACPM or CPME, or APMA. Well, it's not going to happen, so please be open, honest and transparent. Your leaders were members of the Woodstock generation; suddenly you are members of the Watergate generation. That is not a compliment. We see through you and we are calling you out. Be authentic and drop the back door mentality of just sneaking by.
It doesn’t do any good for those of us who are happy with the last 50 years of podiatry to write letters and remind the younger malcontent podiatrists that they should be happy with what they have. That sage advice sounds like it came from my Mother who grew up during the depression. The truth is, nothing is going to change for anyone with a DPM degree today. Those of us with that DPM degree for 50 years ought to be striving to keep the spirit of podiatry alive while offering the next generations a path to a DO degree, and perceived podiatric happiness in a future I will never see.
But, we have to respect their choices. Remember how attendings and residency directors treated us like crap with no apparent reason? When we became residency directors we thought it was our turn to get even, but everything changed and residents became equals with feelings. That’s what’s happening now.
We must lay the groundwork and strive to create a DO podiatrist with a plenary license; we must strive to preserve the essence and spirit of podiatry that we worked so damn hard to achieve. This DO podiatrist will have to carry on what all of us have built; being the very best individuals when it comes to foot and ankle care, especially with diabetics. There are going to be more osteopaths. The question is whether some of them will be osteopathic podiatrists or whatever name is christened.
Here’s where the blowback and resistance will come. The podiatry “us” is going to go away. At some point DOs will outnumber the DPMs and that calculus will continue until the last DPM turns off the nail dust evacuator. You and I will never see it happen, but there will be no APMA, no CPME, no AACPM which will be the first podiatry alphabet to perish and the ABFAS will cease doing business as we know it. There will not be enough podiatrists to support these groups. Oddly, these things are not necessary for podiatry to exist. Think about it. Accreditation will be by the osteopathic organizations, ANSI and ANAB with ACGME will accredit a hybrid DO residency that furnishes the DOs with their full license and two years of foot and ankle training.
In the beginning, DPMs will have to be involved in the training of these DO foot specialists. The survey tells us this is what the young want, not what the old politicians think they want because they know what’s best for the kids. Is it worth it? It doesn’t matter what you and I think. The future belongs to the next generations and they may or may not choose feet, but they will choose an unlimited medical license, regardless of what you or I think. Our job is to see that we keep the spirit and essence of podiatry alive, albeit with different initials after their name.
APMA’s last act may be to award an all expense trip to Sandals (with orthotics) to whomever comes up with a new name for this new DO specialty. I chose Sandals as a destination because they are more open than AACPM.
Rod Tomczak, DPM, MD, EdD, Columbus, OH
Other messages in this thread:
05/22/2025 Allen M. Jacobs, DPM
Podiatry and Cardiac Escape Beats (Rod Tomczak, DPM, MD, EdD)
Some years ago, I was serving on the credentials committee at a large hospital in St. Louis when a DO orthopedic surgeon applied for staff. The discussion, led by the MD chairperson, was that "we" (i.e.-medicine) did not recognize his DO residency nor his DO board certification. He was denied staff access. Prior to that, while in high school, college, and podiatry school, I worked as a surgical retractor holder and then as a scrub nurse in several major Philadelphia hospitals. Never did I see a DO in these hospitals, nor any positive references to the DO degree.
Today, 11% of medical school graduates hold a DO degree, and schools of osteopathic medicine are rapidly multiplying. With no reference points other than common sense, I suspect the majority, not all, but the majority of students entering osteopathic medicine colleges do so as a second choice to obtaining an MD degree. Similarly, I suspect those attending Gulf of America medical colleges on some island do so as a second choice, not a first choice.
Tom Brady, whom some consider the greatest quarterback in NFL history, was not a first, second, third or even fourth round draft selection. Brock Purdy, the last draft choice in the 2022 draft, euphemistically referred to as Mr. Irrelevant, just signed a contract for over 200 million dollars to quarterback the San Francisco 49ers. 181 million guaranteed.
Podiatry and podiatrists have similar historical characteristics to the osteopathic profession and the fact that unselected does not mean incapable or incompetent. It means there are only so many available seats it medical colleges. Conversely, hold an MD degree does not guarantee ethical or competent care.
Is St. Louis a microcosm of podiatry? I do not know. However, this is what I see. We have 15 residents in our local program, and there are days when there are so many surgical cases that the residents cannot cover them all. And not all local DPMs work with the residents. The hospitals in St. Louis are hiring DPMs to provide foot and ankle care. If so inclined to do so, there are numerous DPMs here doing TAR's, ankle fractures, major reconstructive surgeries, arthroscopic ankle surgeries on a routine basis.
There are many DPMs who are so busy that appointments are not available to 2-3 months. There are DPMs making a very solid income and are respected by the medical community providing routine office-based care for commonly encountered foot problems. There are DPMs who are fully integrated into orthopedic groups, practicing with orthopedic surgeons, medical groups, and the VA. There are podiatrists at the medical colleges.
I recently referred a patient to interventional cardiology whom I believed had a serious PAD requiring urgent care. The patient was also very anemic and was scheduled for GI scopes to evaluate the anemia. The cardiologist called me to ask MY opinion whether or not the intervention for PAD should take priority over the anemia work-up, since the hemoglobin was 7.6. The priority for care was left to me. My point? Respect for the DPM as an equal member of the healthcare team.
The fact that many DPMs would rather have a DO or MD degree is not a condemnation on the DPM degree. How many osteopaths would rather have an MD degree ? Why not do a survey, would you rather drive a Porsche rather than a Ford. Would you rather have a $10,000,000 home than a $700,000 home.
Not everyone wants to treat feet, or rectal abscess, or cancer. Here in St. Louis, they have had unfilled orthopedic fellowships in foot and ankle. I am able to do everything I need to do. I take skin grafts from the thigh when needed. I do ankle and calcaneal fractures. I do "at risk" foot care. I treat neuropathy. I am able to do anything required to manage foot and ankle pathology. I am addressed as doctor by MD, DO, NP, all the medical staff. It was not always like this, but it is now. Would a DO degree change the "appeal" to be a podiatrist. I continually see names with DPM, MD listed who practice only podiatry, and do not and cannot by law practice medicine. If a legitimate MD or DO degree were obtained, on what basis do we conclude that the number of podiatrists would increase? This is a theoretical proposition. It is theory only.
We are a society with increasing demand for podiatry services. It has been estimated that 1/3 of the US population will require foot and ankle services. Diabetes is increasing. We have an ageing population. We have more people engaged in sporting activities. We have an immigrant population from countries with high rates of diabetes. We have patients with disorders with with which foot and ankle disorders are associated.
To some extent, podiatry is a victim of its own success. We have become so integrated into medicine that many do not realize they are receiving care from a DPM, and quality care at that. The 3-year residency and fellowship is desired provide the graduate to follow a career in many specific areas of foot and ankle care. There are former residents from the St. Louis residency teaching orthopedic residents foot and ankle surgery. Like osteopathy, that would never have been the case 40 years ago.
Oddly enough, in some manner the podiatry education model is more practical than allopathic medicine. Explain to me why a failure to complete an OB/GYN rotation limits me as a podiatrist. If I know that I am going to be treating foot and ankle pathology, my future patients would benefit from time spend in vascular disease, rheumatology, trauma, dermatology, infectious disease, rather than gastroenterology, urology, and less related subspecialties. And by the way at PCPM 1969-1973 we DID a full course in psychiatry, internal medicine, including clinic rotations.
I left prepared to treat foot and ankle disorders, not a pheochromcytoma or sphenoidal wing tumor. If I need an orthopedic surgeon, I do not need him or her to know how to deliver a baby or place a catheter or chest tube. If I need a gynecologist, I could care less if they know how many bones are in a food, or the fate of Rathke's pouch.
How do we address the college admission question? Let people know that you are a DPM. stop saying you graduated medical school. put DPM on your white coat, not "Dr". Let everyone know that the competent and concerned care they are receiving is from a DPM, so that others come to understand what that degree represents. Show some pride for what this profession has accomplished. get off your self-serving ass and make efforts to move the profession forward, something the APMA leadership has in recent years failed to do. get involved in your state and local societies. teach students, residents. lecture at md and do seminars, hospital programs, educational programs for NPs and PAs.
Allen M. Jacobs, DPM, St. Louis, MO
05/21/2025 David Secord, DPM
Podiatry and Cardiac Escape Beats (Rod Tomczak, DPM, MD, EdD)
I started out as an electrical engineer, attending Milwaukee School of Engineering. My roommate and I ended up becoming best friends and it is funny how our lives progressed. I moved to South Texas and worked as a telecommunications engineer. Kevin went on to build Formula I engines for A.J. Foyt Racing. We both eventually chose a path in medicine. Because of my experience of tearing up my right ankle playing basketball at The University of Dallas, I wanted to do foot and ankle as a profession and attended the Temple School (PCPM at the time.) Kevin attended a DO school and is an ER doctor in Las Vegas, after serving some time in the Navy.
When we reconnected some years back, he was interested in my choice and I was interested in his choice. I never considered applying to a DO school for a good reason: what I wanted to treat. When I moved to South Texas, I ended up entering the seminary to study for the Diocese of Corpus Christi. I became friends with three individuals, all of whom left the seminary—as I did—and became doctors. All of them wanted to be surgeons. None of them ended up in the top 10% of their classes, went through the “scramble” and ended up being (respectively) a pathologist, a radiologist and a pediatrician. None of them wanted to do this for a living but they had bills to pay and a family to support.
Last week, I repaired a woman’s mid-shaft fibular fracture in non-union after her tibial fracture was repaired via an IM rod, four years ago. The fibular fractures in this scenario are never addressed, the action of the IM rod leaves the fibular fracture bayoneted and the patient with a limb-length discrepancy. After dealing with the prominence and the pain of the non-union, she is delighted with the surgical result. No more prominence. No more pain with translation of the tibia and fibula during gait. It is this sort of moment which keeps me getting up in the morning and looking forward to seeing patients.
This is also the unique aspect of podiatry. You know that if your interest is the area below the knee, that is what you are going to do for a living. Dr. Tomczak is exactly right in that the missing piece to the puzzle in our profession is plenary licensure. Holding a license which allows treatment throughout the patient’s needs but allows specialization upon those maladies below the knee is the future. It is inevitable. The path was carved out through the wilderness by our forefathers. We now have to establish a settlement and raise a flag entitled: DO/DPM.
David Secord, DPM, McAllen, TX
05/21/2025 Ivar E. Roth, DPM, MPH
Podiatry and Cardiac Escape Beats (Rod Tomczak, DPM, MD, EdD)
Dr. Tomczak wrote. “As of this week, AACPM will not answer or even acknowledge my calls.”
I want to chime in here. I have also called AACPM several times over 3 weeks and sent e mails as well with no response until I literally left a rather pissed off voice mail and e mail to them explaining that if I did not get a response, heads would roll. I finally got a response email that was not signed and claimed, “Due to the small size of our staff, we always recommend people reach out via email with any questions or issues.”
The problem with this response is I had written several previous e mails and called and heard nothing. Finally, after threatening heads would roll, I got a phone call back. The person that called could NOT explain what my concerns were showing me that they or NO ONE ever listened to my detailed messages that I left.
These organization are a symptom of our times and think that it is okay to blow off requests and that no one will care or bother to complain and so it’s business as usual. The same problem exists at the APMA. I called many times and emailed and the response was to say the least, pathetic. While I am a dues-paying CPMA member I decided NOT to pay the APMA dues this year until I see some progress, so far, I am not impressed. We give them our hard-earned money for what?
Ivar E. Roth, DPM, MPH, Newport Beach, CA
|
|
|
|
|